Good afternoon ladies,
Today’s post will be about our experience with a home school/public school options program.
There are many homeschool programs now that are offered by the public school systems. I am glad that there are different choices for families to make who chose the public school route. To many kids fall through the cracks and the various options afforded to families of public school children are definitely something for them to consider.
I love homeschooling. I think it is wonderful. When one of my younger children was in Jr. high she decided that she wanted to go to public school and began expressing that desire to myself and her father. He was behind it 100% and had developed a different world view from my own. Between the teenager and the father, the pressure they were exerting, made for a very stressful situation for myself. I prayed and asked the Lord to show me what to do. The decision I made was meant to “keep the peace” for all parties involved. (It is hard to make everyone happy and divorced parents are required to make decisions that our married friends do not have to go through.) I enrolled my daughter in a public school option program with classes one day a week for her 8th grade year. For her 9th grade year, the program became 2 days a week with a horrible class schedule. If she was not in a class then I had to go and get her from across town and “babysit” in the parking lot for an hour until she went to her next class. It put such a damper on our homeschool at home and my work schedule.
Here are my pro’s and con’s on that experience.
Pro’s:
Excellent computer teacher and classes
Excellent science teacher and classes
O.K. Geography teacher and classes
My daughter made a close friend and the girls were inseparable during high school.
Cons:
There was a “dumbing down” in the academic standards compared to the work we did at home. My daughter really noticed it. (Mom gets a point here, since I had forewarned her of that possibility. It was nice that she eventually saw that.)
Class selection enrollment was doled out based on who you were and who you knew. The rest of us got what was left over. If your child did not get the necessary classes in their high school program, they could not graduate. This seemed so unfair, since many classes were not available to all the students to begin with. I hope that in the last 7-8 years they remedied that situation.
What started out as a homeschool program quickly became a regular public school, thus losing its original purpose for more parental involvement. Every year the government control became greater.
With the lower academic standards came lower behavior rules and double standards in the disciplinary system. While my child was not a behavior problem, other families expressed their concerns about the situation.
My child who “pushed” the rules and attitudes at home now found an outlet for more of this with this public school program.
Parents were required to volunteer 40 hours of time at the school cleaning, helping with office tasks, and other chores. This is a good idea and I supported it. However, the volunteer hours were given out first based on ”who you knew and who you were” with the rest of us scrambling to volunteer on the days our kids were in class so we did not have to make extra trips back to the school. This part was extremely frustrating. Parents could opt out of the volunteer work by paying a size-able fee to the school. Not an option for a single momma.
The school was a ways from home and necessitated numerous trips there during the days class was in session. Frequently, my other child and I sat in the car and did school work while we waited. This was not fun in the hot or extremely cold weather.
Staff, teachers, parents, and students were not allowed to talk about God. This school seemed overzealous in this area and took away student rights in my opinion. Remember, this is my opinion only. It seemed so ironic to me that the school met in a church and yet God could not be mentioned.
The music program was pathetic. My daughter was in the music program. Her spring concert was a memorable event. After a year of musical instruction, the band played selections such as “Go Tell Aunt Rhody” and “Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star”. (The homeschool co-op we joined had a more demanding program which my kids excelled in.)
The second month into my daughter’s 9th grade year in this program, she begged desperately to be un-enrolled from the program. Knowing her father the way I do, I told her she had to finish out the school year. She was also learning valuable computer skills which I could not teach her at that time. I took her out of the school over the summer and she then happily attended classes at our homeschool co-op until she graduated.
As the first and only single homeschooling parent they had ever heard of, I was interrogated frequently over everything from my curriculum at home to my work schedule to my living conditions. The top brass did the constant questioning. In their minds, only married folks could successfully homeschool and placed all homeschoolers in a square box of their making. (Girls, I know you understand the constant struggle to have to prove yourself, your family, and what God has called you to do.) I kept telling them that I had been homeschooling since 1989 (longer than all of them), that I owned my own business, car, and had even bought a house with a real mortgage. It was such a novelity to them. For me the questioning got old very quickly.
My overall views on the option program we were in:
I thought it was a major waste of time and taxpayer dollars. I hope that some of the problems that plagued the school have been worked out and that the present students have a more pleasant experience.
The computer and science classes were excellent and I am glad my daughter made such a close girlfriend.
If I had to do it again, would I? It is always easy to say “I should have or shouldn’t have” after the fact. The bottom line is that I had to deal with dad and the court system and had to follow the divorce decree. So I made the best decision that I could at the time. It was an OK experience with it’s good and bad points just like any other experience. For my daughter’s sophomore year, she turned 16 and that was the mandatory age at which a student could drop out of school if they so chose. When she did not want to go back to the public school option program, I made her tell her dad her reasons why. While he did not like it, he accepted it much better from her than from me. She very happily finished out her formal education at home and loved our homeschool co-op. I will be writing about the co-op experience in my next post.
If I did not have to deal with an ex-husband, I would not have used this program.
I still made my daughter complete her curriculum with our regular work at home. The “dumbing down” academic standards really bothered me.
Now girls, some folks absolutely loved the public school option programs and let everyone know that. I really respect their choices and their happy memories.
It just was not for us.
L.
Remember you’re not alone in your decisions, we’re all in this together.
Copyright 2010